Category Archives: Ports

Labor disruption coming for supply chains

Now is the time for labor unions to press ports and railways for new benefits for workers. There is a perfect storm of labor stoppages about to take place.

Thursday (that’s two days from this writing) the Teamsters Canada union (TCRC) expects to strike the CPKC railroad, one of the two largest in Canada. CPKC is also a large US and Mexico railway, and we’ve yet to see if US unions will honor a Canadian strike. The Canadian National (CN) rail line has blocked the strike by giving a lockout notice to the union. So there’s a high likelihood that most Canadian rail shipments will be shut down later this week.

The TCRC has turned down offers made in January, April and May. The labor agreements with the rails expired at the end of 2023, and the workers are working under the old contract. There have also been some rules changes by the government to reduce fatigue, that are not accounted for in the contracts. In fact, the union claims the rails want to ‘gut the collective agreement of all safety-critical fatigue provisions’. That may be hyperbole, but it’s indicative of the bitterness of disagreement.

The Teamsters represent about 10,000 workers. The Labor Minister has not issued an order for binding arbitration, so it’s likely there will be stoppages.

The cessation of rail movements means there are likely to be major disruptions at ports, where rail takes goods into the interior of Canada and also to the US. The rails are already announcing embargos which mean that they will not accept new shipments in certain areas because of expected port congestion.

The Port of Vancouver has already ordered ships on their way there to slow-steam because they fear they will not be able to move cargo out or into the port.

To top off the labor confusion, the US East Coast Ports are engaged in negotiations with the International Longshoremens Association (ILA), the major union representing 85,000 members. The ILA has indicated that October 1 will begin a strike if a new contract is not agreed. There does not seem to be a clear path to agreement.

Shippers and Ocean Carriers are already preparing. Cargo is shifting to the West Coast US Ports, where an agreement was completed last year. I expect the East Coast ILA members expect similar if not better contracts, because East Coast ports have been prospering for the last couple of years. Their first glitch was when the Panama Canal reduced its traffic due to an extended drought. Traffic started shifting to the West Coast then. Now the Panama Canal is near its former levels, and traffic is rising again. The East Coast Ports do not need a strike right now.

But that’s exactly why the unions are playing hardball.

We’ll see how it plays out.

FreightWaves Staff· Monday, August 19, 2024

Teamsters Canada Rail Conference delivers strike notice to CPKC; CN delivers lockout notice

By Charlotte Goldstone 20/08/2024

Congestion ‘rearing its disruptive and costly head’ as Canada rail strike looms

UPDATE: Rail contract talks continuing; Vancouver port acts ahead of possible stoppage

Seatrade logo

Nick Savvides | Aug 16, 2024

US East Coast port strike the next spanner in supply chains

By David Ljunggren August 19, 20249:10 AM MST Updated a day ago

Explainer: Why Canada is on the verge of an unprecedented rail labor stoppage

Port call optimisation reduces greenhouse gas emissions in ports

Drewry is well-known for its expertise in maritime-related matters. In a recent market opinion piece, they suggest that maritime emissions can be reduced rather simply, with port call optimization. They mean to reduce the time ships sit near a port waiting for their berth to open up.

Some ports have been successful with appointment windows. But the Drewry approach includes slow steaming to hit the port berthing window close to the time, instead of standing offshore running engines and emitting pollution. The slow steaming itself is a tested measure for reducing emissions, though it doesn’t eliminate them. The two efforts combined could save a lot of pollution, and now in some places such as the EU, emission charges based on actual fuel use numbers.

Eliminating waste in a system, such as waiting time waste, is a tried and true operations management or lean technique. But in the case of maritime shipping and ports, a lot of coordination is required. Systems need to be in place to provide accurate information about ocean carrier voyage schedules. Sailing times between ports can vary a lot, because of factors such as weather and route adjustments.

But also, both ocean carriers and ports need to share information and cooperate on setting berthing schedules. A late loading in Shanghai, for instance, will affect the projected arrival time in Long Beach. the two ports and the carrier will need to share up-to-the-minute (or hour) information about progress. Will they do it? It will require a level of interaction never before seen.

I think that ultimately, ports and carriers will be driven to this by the gains that can be made. but I think it will be a long time coming.

Update: Port optimization can actually prevent deaths. Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (HKUST) has recently studied the number of deaths that could be prevented by port waiting time improvement.

Sam Chambers June 27, 2024

Port efficiency gains can save 10,000 premature deaths annually

10 Jun 2024

https://www.drewry.co.uk/maritime-research-opinion-browser/maritime-research-opinions/port-call-optimisation-is-key-to-reducing-greenhouse-gas-emissions-in-ports

ILA stops negotiations with USMX

The labor deal between US East and Gulf Coast ports and the International Longshoreman’s Association (ILA) may be unraveling. The current agreement expires at the end of September. It was a six-year deal.

The major issue at present is an Auto Gate system Maersk and APM Terminals are using that processes trucks autonomously, with no ILA labor. The union claims this directly contradicts what was agreed in the last union contract.

Automation and protection of ILA jobs have for years now been a bone of contention between the union and the alliance of container carriers, direct employers, and port associations that serve US ports, which is called the United States Maritime Alliance (USMX). The same was true on the West Coast, when the recent strike was averted by a new contract with the Pacific Maritime Association.

There’s no easy way to find resolution. Automation reduces jobs for longshoremen, though it creates support jobs, for which most union longshoremen are not qualified. And retraining these longshoremen may be difficult, even if some way could be found to fund it. Each side thinks the other ought to pay for the retraining. And in the short run, there will still be a workforce reduction.

The September 30, 2024 expiration date looks like it may not be met; however both sides have usually agreed to continue work as usual while still negotiating. However, openly violating terms of the contract, especially without full discussion with the union, is a good way to get their dander up, and prolong the negotiations.

Best to practice transparency and full disclosure.

Logistics Management logo

By Jeff Berman June 10, 2024

https://www.logisticsmgmt.com/article/ila_stops_negotiations_with_usmx_with_deal_set_to_expire_at_the_end_of_september